New Policy Means Coaches Can't be Their Own Supervisors
Policy enacted to resolve conflicts of interest that may arise due to extenuating circumstances.
The Board of Education approved a new policy Thursday prohibiting administrators and supervisors from coaching sports teams or acting as advisors of any district athletic, co-curricular, or extra-curricular program.
The Board said in November that it would address such conflicts after nine Wayne Hills High School football players, including 18-year-old star wide receiver Andrew Monaghan, were charged with aggravated assault after they allegedly attacked two Wayne Valley High School students Oct. 29.
Parents and residents had criticized Hills football coach Chris Olsen for not suspending the players for the team’s first two state playoff games; Olsen is also the school’s athletic director.
Olsen is not the only supervisor this policy affects.
Wayne Valley High School Athletic Director Dan Kilday coaches the boys’ varsity soccer team at Valley. He and Olsen will not be allowed to coach their teams and be the athletic directors of their respective institutions after July 1. They will have to choose in which capacity they want to remain at the district.
The policy also prohibits individuals from being an assistant coach or assistant advisor.
The policy states that “any situation requiring decisions as to action taken in extenuating circumstances as it pertains to an athletic team, co-curricular, or extra-curricular club are made by a member of the school district’s administrative or supervisory staff. As such, a member of the district’s administrative or supervisory staff cannot serve as his/her own supervisor.”
Superintendent Ray Gonzalez said that the policy was enacted to “address potential conflicts that may arise when staff members who serve in administrative roles assume coaching and/or advisory responsibilities.”
District officials said that the policy was not enacted because of any one person.
“It’s not about one person or another, it is to resolve the conflict of interest that you’re reporting to yourself,” said Board trustee Robyn Kingston, “especially when you’re coaching and being an athletic director.
“We’re simply showing that we’re following through with the commitment that we made to the district.”
Board President Donald Pavlak Jr. could not be reached for comment.
Kingston also said that enacting the policy will not cost the district more money since advisors and coaches are already paid for their roles in extracurricular activities, in addition to their regular salaries.
Olsen and Kilday did not return phone calls seeking comment.
stewart resmer
8:08 pm on Friday, January 6, 2012
works for me
Ron
8:44 pm on Friday, January 6, 2012
makes total sense
Kit Rogers
8:47 pm on Friday, January 6, 2012
How was he acting as his own supervisor when he was following what the acting super and the boe told him what to do?
Dory Degen
11:26 am on Sunday, January 8, 2012
Thats the point...he wasn't! Olsen bullied the BOE into doing what HE wanted to do. Rewind 2 months and read all about it!
K H
9:58 pm on Friday, January 6, 2012
As a public school teacher in another district I think this is a superb policy. I hope it sets a precedent throughout the state of New Jersey.
John M
1:05 am on Saturday, January 7, 2012
No it is about Olsen who are they kidding! I guess that would include drama, chess team, debating team, dance team, cheerleading, band etc. or is it Just football in Hills & Soccer in Valley.
Bobtwo
8:22 am on Saturday, January 7, 2012
Is there additional pay for having the second position? I assume tat there is.
John Lynch
9:31 am on Saturday, January 7, 2012
Bobtwo yes if you are an A.D. and coach you get paid for both positions. Your A.D. salary and whatever the sty pen amount is for what you are coaching, the amount varies by sport.
Resident Kelly
8:32 am on Saturday, January 7, 2012
I can't believe this hasn't been addressed before. In Clifton they passed this rule a few years ago. No coach can be a coach and the AD. In Bloomfield, same rule applies. I don't know Wayne is always so far behind. You would think a town of this size would be a leader not a follower.
Paul Karsevar
9:29 am on Saturday, January 7, 2012
Kudos to the board for getting this done. You learn from your mistakes and that is what they did. I do not know Mr. Olsen but do know Mr. Kilday and I am sure he will miss being on the field with his soccer teams if he decides to stay on as AD. I am sure Mr. Olsen will have a difficult decision to make as well. But this is for the benefit of everyone.
eyes wide shut
9:50 am on Saturday, January 7, 2012
Thank GOD, he's OUT with the tide...Don't let that cabin door hit him in the butt on the way out
Dory Degen
11:59 am on Saturday, January 7, 2012
finally some sanity in wayne!
Al Scala
2:05 pm on Saturday, January 7, 2012
It's nice to see that our BOE has rectified a bad decision they made at an earlier time. Better late than never!
Kelly Lonigan
12:36 am on Sunday, January 8, 2012
Olsen should not be allowed to continue as AD, He was derelict in his duties as AD relating to the football episode. He gets paid in excess of 100,000 for being AD and 1/10th of that as football coach. What do you think he will choose? he will continue to manipulate his players away from playing other sports and have selective and arbitrary enforcement of rules based upon his own criteria. He doesnt respect most of the other sports so why let him continue as AD? He will somehow manipulate the BOE and still have his hands all over the day to day of the football team but not have the title. Who are we kidding here? He was never allowed to be both AD and coach but the BOE caved to his demands just a few years ago and then had to follow suit with Kilday. Now Kilday gets punished for olsen's indescretions
Adam Smith
9:17 am on Sunday, January 8, 2012
All this BOE knows is to raise more taxes in April for its own satisfaction.
Joe videodummy
12:18 pm on Sunday, January 8, 2012
Known as the Do-si-do: A movement in square dancing in which two dancers approach each other and circle back to back, then return to their original positions.
This is the call that signals the start of the movement.
Not to be confused with the teachers and administrators leash laws that generally require our finest educators to be under control when-ever they are on school property.
Has there been any word about updating our school website ? A student portal will have a greater positive effect on all of our students and parents, especially those that don't wish to participate in administrative rituals and dances.
martha
3:24 pm on Sunday, January 8, 2012
anything that keeps Kilday away from running (ruining) wayne athletics is a good thing!
Kelly Lonigan
5:16 pm on Sunday, January 8, 2012
there are school districts in Nj and across the country where respected and intelligent individuals successfully maintain the AD job while coaching . You just need a man/woman with integrity. Why didnt the board just fire Olsen as AD since he didnt do his job? Just another cop-out buy the BOE by not being able to make a concrete decision. Did olsen go in front of the Board that night as Coach or AD?
Kit Rogers
6:45 pm on Sunday, January 8, 2012
So dory do you really think the kids got to play bc Olsen bullied the boe? Were you in the closed door session? Did you see the evidence presented? Do you know why they let them play?????
Dory Degen
8:58 pm on Sunday, January 8, 2012
yes, i followed the whole debacle very closely. thank you kit.
martha
7:02 pm on Sunday, January 8, 2012
this just in, new superintendent has announced the hiring if an assistant to the assistant superintendent to be the liason to the assistant in charge of assisting with assisting the athletic directors, calling it a great hire to assist the district!
Dory Degen
8:58 pm on Sunday, January 8, 2012
ha! that was great martha!
Bob
8:09 pm on Monday, January 9, 2012
What a bunch of crap, this should never have been allowed to start with and now that he is under the gun they pretend like their doing something. After the public outcry about the fight he should have been sent packing, the BOE will always dance around what really needs to be done to set things right in Wayne.
rudy
8:51 pm on Monday, January 9, 2012
How is holding the athletic director and coaches position any different from a a department chair teaching in the classroom?
What really needs to be addressed is the lack of oversight, action and concern exhibited by our administrators at the school and BOE offices. How do you justify salaries well in excess of $100,000 without the brains or guts to make a black and white decision. When will this board realize that problems will not be answered by additional policy, positions and salaries as long as they continue to govern selfishly and hire blindly? Our teachers, administrators and boe trustees need to do the job expected of them without looking for political advancement or union favor?
So to the superintendent and Ms. Kingston, I would submit to you that your policy is flawed by a selfish desire to demote a recognized leader with a strong following and will result in addition dollars thrown into the black hole that our district has become without any recognizable benefit.
Can't we do better?
Beavis
12:01 pm on Wednesday, January 11, 2012
One could say this about our current US Government also...
Kelly Lonigan
8:53 pm on Monday, January 9, 2012
he will remain as coach and they will just find another 100,000 position for him somewhere else in the school system. I am surprised they didnt just make him Superintendent or Asst Superintendent since he runs the show anyway. No penalty for not doing his job at AD I guess. he spit intheir faces and they seem to enjoy it.
rudy
9:19 pm on Monday, January 9, 2012
Since we are talking about those who didn't do the job they were hired to do, get rid of the principal, vice principal and anyone who was supposed to be in charge at the boe offices. Tell Roth to return his per diem since he advised the district the players could not sit until he felt the heat and reversed. They all had a chance to step up and voice an opinion, quote a policy or demand better. Not one of them had the guts, Which policy addresses cowardice?
You answered my point perfectly. He is set, and may even choose to stay as AD since that will allow him to hire his replacement. Anyone who feels Coach Olsen runs the "show" must realize he is protected by a union put into power by former board decisions and parents lulled into promoting the union line of crap.
I don't know, maybe he would have been better suited for superintendent over another who's first decision is to hire an assistant for $160,000 because he's realizing he is in over his head!.
Rich
9:25 pm on Monday, January 9, 2012
Well done. Time to move on.
Kelly Lonigan
9:46 pm on Monday, January 9, 2012
but isnt he truly the Superintendent? The BOE cowers to him. And they have caved into his every whim for years. They show no embarrassment by their behavior. and it continues
rudy
10:14 pm on Monday, January 9, 2012
and if that is indeed true, shame on the entire wayne school district!
Kit Rogers
7:29 am on Tuesday, January 10, 2012
Kelly you have a lot to say about mr Olsen and seem to think he possesses super powers.....it's just funny
Justice
8:27 am on Tuesday, January 10, 2012
How did the assistant super get approved on my dime?
Kelly Lonigan
8:51 am on Tuesday, January 10, 2012
kit, do u think its funmny to have an AD in place that puts football ahead of all other sports? An AD that gives his own players special treatment? An AD that prohibits students from participating in other sports? An AD that does not allow other teams to use the snack bar, the lights, the sound system , the cafeteria? An AD that challenged the Board of Ed on punishments they see fit ...that the AD has given out to other players on other teams quite regularly? I dont think its funny at all and I think its sad that you are another brain-washed fool.
Kit Rogers
8:59 am on Tuesday, January 10, 2012
I don't know where you get your information. I really don't. There are many kids who play football lacrosse baseball track basketball or hockey. With regard to the snack stand, each game is given to a different sports teams parents to run it. It is however the football parents who stock the place and keep inventory. I know this bc I have kids on other teams and have worked the stand myself for those teams.
I never said one way or the other if an ad should be able to coach so don't put words in my mouth..... Call me brainwashed, call me a fool,,,,,you are clearly bitter and that is what is funny.
Dory Degen
8:19 pm on Tuesday, January 10, 2012
mean people suck.
Kit Rogers
9:18 pm on Tuesday, January 10, 2012
Thnx dory. I agree!
Gordon Rizzuto
2:02 am on Sunday, January 15, 2012
Being AD and a coach is a big conflict of interest especially when it's Olsen. I have friends that go to both Wayne schools. I have a couple friends that graduated from Wayne Hills that can't stand Olsen. They weren't allowed to play in their sport because they got Accused of things. They told me if they had been accused of doing what those 9 boys did they wouldn't have been allowed to play. However they also haven't graduated recently so Olsen may have changed his ways. I doubt it though.
Kelly Lonigan
2:24 pm on Monday, January 16, 2012
be careful. the forum police might call you bitter and mean for such an opinion!! whers there is smoke, there is fire
Kit Rogers
3:47 pm on Monday, January 16, 2012
no kelly, i actually respect your opinion and believe that everyone has a right to same. It just bothers me when you spout things that are rumors and you come across as bitter. thats all.....oh and btw im pretty sure you called me brainwashed and a fool for my opinion so can we call it even?
Dory Degen
10:05 pm on Wednesday, January 18, 2012
this forum police officer was referring to "kit," not you kelly.
Kelly Lonigan
11:31 pm on Monday, January 16, 2012
well if i have first hand knowledge, second hand kowledge and 3rd hand knowledge of my allegations so i of course would not classify them as rumors. i'm glad you had a better experience then most but that does not discount other people's encounters. many many people have similar stories to mine throughout the years. if you choose to not believe them that is certainly your perogative, but that does not make them untrue. I am not bitter at all. Why does stating fact make someone appear bitter? Should i just sit in the corner and be a good boy and keep my mouth closed because it would make you happy?
Kit Rogers
10:50 pm on Wednesday, January 18, 2012
Jeez dory, i thought you meant kellynwhen she called me a brainwashed fool. Silly of me. For the record I am really not a mean person.
Dory Degen
12:01 pm on Monday, February 6, 2012
so you just sound like one. ok.